Chlorophyll content in different plants

PhotosynQ SPAD comparison

Thumb sam 0645   copy   copy  2

Dan TerAvest

May 2015

Loading..
Loading..

It looks like when measuring wheat, we are not doing a good job of completely covering the light guides, resulting in very poor correlation between the Minolta SPAD and PQ SPAD values.

Compare the wheat graph to the apple leaf graph (which has much wider leaves), and you can see that the correlation for apple leaves is very good, almost 0.93

  • created

    May 2015

  • last reply

    May 2015

  • replies

    2

  • users

    2

  • Thumb sam 0645   copy   copy  2
  • Thumb 012409 pbi 160 low low res headshot
Thumb 012409 pbi 160 low low res headshot

Greg Austic

May 2015

Here here! This is an important lesson for us to learn though, as many of our users will probably have similar experiences. It's hard with small leaves to really know if you're completely covering the light guide or not... and honestly for all we know they are covering it but there's enough leakage if it's a tight fit that's causing problems.

I want to note also though that not only is the r2 a whopping .93 but the slope is 0.9... which means we're actually pretty spot on.

Is this over multiple devices, or just one device? I'm curious to begin seeing device / device variation as I imagine it's not insignificant.

Greg

Thumb 012409 pbi 160 low low res headshot

Greg Austic

May 2015

Oh, also I wanted to note that this was using only a single device. I'm sure if we add more devices our variation goes up, though I'm curious to see how much.

Let's make a new Project and focus on device to device variation over different crops (now that the skinny leaf issues is addressed and folks are better trained). The outcomes would be:

1) How much variation in the r2, m and b values in the correlation are there between MultispeQ devices to a single SPAD device?

2) Does total variation or variation by device change over different plant types?

This is a good first step for Eric early this week, actually, you maybe just pass it off to Veronica or Ryan. Whoever does it let's make sure to link to it in the discussion section here.

Greg

Greg